ENGLISH
FIRST
Mr. VANCE (for himself and Mr. CRAMER) introduced the following bill:
To declare English as the official language of the United States, to establish a uniform English language rule for naturalization, and to avoid mis-constructions of the English language texts of the laws of the United States, pursuant to Congress’ powers to provide for the general welfare of the United States and to establish a uniform rule of naturalization under Article I, section 8, of the Constitution.
Why have an official language
English
While recognizing the value of linguistic diversity, establishing English as the official language of the United States would bring about several significant benefits:
​
National Unity and Shared Identity: A common language fosters a sense of unity and shared national identity among citizens. It facilitates communication and understanding across different communities, promoting social cohesion and cultural integration.
​
Improved Communication and Efficiency: Having a designated official language streamlines government operations, legal proceedings, and public services. It reduces the need for costly translations and interpretations, ensuring clear and efficient communication between the government and its citizens.
​
Economic Benefits: English proficiency is crucial for economic success in the U.S. Making it the official language encourages immigrants to learn English, enhancing their employment opportunities, earning potential, and overall economic integration.
​
Educational Advancement: A unified language of instruction in schools simplifies educational resources and promotes equal learning opportunities for all students. It ensures that everyone has access to the same quality of education, regardless of their linguistic background.
​
Historical Precedent: English has been the dominant language of the U.S. since its founding and plays a vital role in its history, culture, and legal system. Formalizing its status as the official language would simply acknowledge this historical reality.
​
Enhanced National Unity and Communication: While English proficiency is rising among immigrants, making it the official language would further encourage its adoption, fostering better communication and understanding among all citizens. A common language is essential for building a cohesive national identity and ensuring all citizens can fully participate in civic life, from accessing government services to voting.
​
Not at Odds with Ideals but Promotes Inclusion: Rather than contradicting American ideals of tolerance and diversity, designating English as the official language would empower individuals by providing them with the tools to navigate American society effectively. It would facilitate participation in the democratic process and economic opportunities, ultimately promoting greater inclusion.
​
Not Discriminatory but Empowers: While concerns about discrimination exist, making English official would actually empower those who do not yet speak it proficiently by incentivizing language acquisition. This would help them overcome barriers to employment, education, and social integration, ultimately improving their lives.
​
National Policy for National Unity: While states currently have the right to determine language policies, establishing English as the official language at the federal level would send a clear message about its importance for national unity and communication. It would create a unified approach to language policy and streamline government operations.
​
Encouraging Bilingualism, Not Loss of Heritage Languages: Making English the official language does not preclude the preservation of heritage languages. In fact, it could be implemented in a way that encourages bilingualism, recognizing the value of multilingualism while ensuring that all citizens have a common language to interact.
​
English Plus Approach: Designating English as the official language does not mean other languages would be discouraged. Instead, it would prioritize English acquisition while acknowledging the benefits of multilingualism. This approach would create a stronger foundation for individuals to learn additional languages while ensuring they have the necessary English skills to succeed in the United States.
​
By addressing the concerns raised in the opposing viewpoint, it becomes clear that making English the official language can be done in a way that promotes unity, inclusivity, and empowerment while preserving linguistic diversity.